Early-release flow data: jumping on a bandwagon?

EPFR’s daily flow data is usually released around 5 pm Eastern Standard Time (EST) the following business day. That is – narrowly — too late to catch the T + 1 market close. Hence, our internal back tests always incorporate a two-day delay.

EPFR does offer, however, an early-release option for its daily data. Clients can get premium daily flow data on a rolling basis, with sequentially more comprehensive deliveries at 9 am Hong Kong time, 9 am London time and 9 am New York time. These delivery times correspond to 9 pm (T + 0), 4 am (T + 1) and 9 am (T + 1) in New York and encompass around 20%, 45% and 85%, respectively, of the assets covered by regular daily flows dataset.

While the directional and sentiment signals provided by premium daily data are obvious, its value as a major, or stand alone, input for trading models remains unproven.

In this article we explore using the most complete early Equity Fund data, released at 9 am New York time, in order to trade at the T + 1 close in New York. This cuts the delay in knowing the flow data in half to just one day.​


Playing the regional card

EPFR classifies each fund by its geographic mandate or focus, where the fund can invest, geographically. Many are country related, such as Germany or Singapore. Others are regionally focused — Latin America, EMEA or Asia ex-Japan – and some have a global focus. The latter include Global Emerging Market (GEM) and Global ex-US funds.

As a result of this clearly defined categorization, one can asset weight daily returns of relevant equity funds to isolate the return to each geographic focus. But can you predict them?

We tried predicting these regional returns using both early-release and regular data. For each trade date (T) and region, we pulled in the regional return for that date (time T), the 9 am New York early release flow from time T – 2 and the regular daily flow from time T – 3. For each region, the flow used – for both early-release and regular data – was the total flow into all funds assigned to that region divided by total starting assets of all the funds.

In order to make an apples-to-apples comparison, we looked only at those trade-date/region pairs where at least one fund appeared in the early-release data. Finally, since we were interested in relative returns to each region on the same trade date, we mean-adjusted the returns so that, for each trade date, the equal-weight average region return was zero.

We then ran regressions of regional return against T – 3 daily flow and T – 2 early-release flow across the entire data set. Our results appear in the table below.

Image of a chart representing "Panel Regressions"

As you can see from our results, neither indicator proved predictive. In no case is our measure of predictive power, the t value (or t-statistic), anywhere near 2. The p-value in the fourth column says there’s, respectively, a 19% and 15% probability that a variable with no predictive power could have yielded a more extreme t-statistic by sheer chance.


One for all, and all for significance

It is an established maxim of military philosophy that concentrating your forces usually produces a better result. Taking a leaf out of this book, we tried to combine our two weak indicators into one, by regressing regional returns on the difference between T – 3 regular flow and T – 2 early-release flow.

Image of a chart representing "T - 3 regular less T - 2 early-release flow"

The results are now almost significant, there being only a 1 in 20 probability that such a high t-statistic could have been achieved by main chance.

Is there a better way to combine the two variables? To find out we regressed regional returns against both variable simultaneously.

Image of a chart representing "Both Indicators"

As you can see from the table, the two indicators want to be combined in a 4:3 proportion, based on the “Estimate” column.

We build our final indicator by subtracting off triple T – 2 early-release flow from quadruple T – 3 regular flow. When we run the regression of regional returns against this one variable, we end up with a significant predictor with a t-value of 2.

Image of a chart representing "4 parts regular less three parts early flow"


Plenty of uplands to be explored

This foray into EPFR’s early-release data suggests that its value to investors is not limited to the indicative. But unlocking its predictive value will take more work.

Some of that work will focus on flows to fixed income fund groups which, in the interests of concision, we did not look at in this piece.

Did you find this useful? Get our EPFR Insights delivered to your inbox.

Related Posts

An unusual visitor comes knocking on Japan’s door. Did it RSVP?

An unusual visitor comes knocking on Japan’s door. Did it RSVP?

After literally decades of being on the losing side despite serial, increasingly massive quantitative easing programs, the Bank of Japan (BOJ) has seen inflation take off, hitting a 42-year high of 4.3% in January of this year. It seems that this time, things really are different. In this Quant’s corner, we will explore whether EPFR’s Fund Flows and Allocation data gave any warning of this sea change in Japanese consumer price inflation (CPI).

Off the wires: Bitcoin is one year away from a major technical event. History suggests the start of another bull run

Off the wires: Bitcoin is one year away from a major technical event. History suggests the start of another bull run

Bitcoin’s next “halving” is expected to take place in 2024. These events take place when Bitcoin miners have added 210,000 “blocks” to the blockchain leger and are marked by a halving of the Bitcoins that miners get for adding each block. Given the implications for future supplies of Bitcoin, these ‘halvings’ usually push Bitcoin’s price significantly higher, both in the run up to the event and for several months afterwards. This time around seems – so far – to be conforming to the pattern: Bitcoin’s price has risen steadily in recent weeks.

Off the wires: US inflation falls to lowest level since May 2021

Off the wires: US inflation falls to lowest level since May 2021

According to CNN, annual inflation dropped in March 2023 for the ninth consecutive month, and grocery prices fell month-on-month for the first time since September 2020. While the CPI has cooled off – at least temporarily – investors are not treating the news as a green light for the road back to riskier asset classes. With fear far from banished, cash remains king.

Better, More Actionable Insights

Let us show you how EPFR can create value for your specific strategy

First Name
Last Name
Email Address
Job Title
Contact Number
View our privacy policy.